Flashers not working, relay question

I just installed led tail lights and headlight, but the relay i have right now is hyper flashing. I went to Advance Auto and got an led compatible relay, but it does not work. It fits in just fine though. Is there anything I can do or do I need to buy another?

Forgot to mention, the relay with 5 prongs is new, the one with 3 is the original relay

you may have the wrong relay. they make a 3 prong for your car.

Awesome, thanks!