New brakes squeak AFTER I remove my foot from the brake pedal!

You could NEVER go wrong with OEM Toyota brakes. They are more expensive, but are built to exacting specifications by Toyota. Aftermarket brakes tend to be hit or miss, and there are some less than desirable brands out there.

Metallic brakes are noisy by nature. If your car originally had ceramic brakes, that is what they should have stuck with. Ceramic brakes are less noisy and tend to last longer.