CarTalk.com Blogs Car Info Our Show Deals Mechanics Files Vehicle Donation

What is all these types of oil for sale?

So my mom gave me her beloved 06 Hyundai Tucson and I was looking at 5W-20 oil to buy for the next oil change as written in the manul. I figured I would go with Mobil 1 since it’s a reputable brand and then I get hit with the big three different bottles

Normal
Fuel Economy
Extended Performance

I just thought of going with normal and just follow the owner’s manual interval but what the hell is all this? Is it simple marketing or what? I’m just looking at having a discussion on this. I’m no expert so I’m really curious.

Also, manual says 6 months or 12k KM. Was that the old days now 1 year is good or should still do it every 6 months?

Do you think it is possible that whoever wrote the manual might just know what they are talking about?

I hear you on the oil types, better to change the oil too often, when I was doing my oil changes, Castrol, then other variations of castrol came up, I have never had to add oil yet, well at 188k and not using synthetic, and whatever stuff my shop puts in, do not even bother to ask, just make sure it meets specs and every 6 months may be overkill but should be a good recommendation to follow. Oil changes are cheaper than engine changes.

I totally agree with the point usually but we’re talking about oil and in 11 years I’m pretty sure the oil has made a lot of technological changes.

Unless it’s not just about the oil itself and I don’t know what I’m talking about.

Understood. The normal Mobil 1 exceeds the specs as stated in the manual so should be good. I’ll buy loads when it’s on sale.

My 330ci BMW was 1 year or 15k KM. Now it’s a consensus the 15k KM was a bit high but 1 year was well within spec (Unless once again I’m mistaken and 1 year isn’t the average). I’m just nondrying why would a Tucson be 6 months.

I guess it’s just because of oil grade? Since Tucson is 20 while on the BMW it was 40? I’m just trying to understand here not trying to refute whoever wrote the manual or engineers with what they came up.

Forget the oil part, the engine was designed over 11 years ago and that is what the builders recommend so go by the manual.

Use the manufacturer recommended fluids.

The Mobil1 extended performance oil has higher additive content to deal with contaminants longer. IIRC, Exxon/Mobil says it can go 15,000 miles between changes. If you follow Hyundai’s recommended oil change protocol, there is no need to spend more on the extended performance oil.

These days everyone wants to feel special and the oil company marketers are doing their part to oblige.

2 Likes

Rod_Knox nails it. Within the synthetic family, I’m sure there are minor formulation changes to the products, but it is mostly marketing. However, the difference between synthetics and “traditional” motor oils is real and easily measurable. It used to be that was the end of it. Then they starting offering blends of synthetic and traditional oils…

There’s likely some benefit to using the other two options, but my guess you’d be better off using the Normal version and changing the oil a little more often. In the early 80’s my auto shop night school teacher told us that the important parameters to match up with what the manufacturer of the car recommends are the viscosity numbers and the API service rating, SN is the most recent oil classification for ordinary passenger vehicles these days.

There used to be a rating for commercial vehicle oils too, or maybe it was diesel engines; instead of S, that one started with C as I recall. Not sure if they still have a rating for that. At the time SF was the best non-commercial oil but there was another one rated CC as I recall, and some brands hosting an CC rating were compatible with cars requiring SF, and that’s what I usually used back then.

http://www.pqiamerica.com/apiserviceclass.htm

IMO, once you decide which oil is good for your car, it’s better to stick with the same brand of oil to minimize any potential additive compatibility problems.

You left out one! There’s Mobil-1 Annual, too.
CSA

P.S. Also, I can’t forget the golf shirts. I saved Mobil-1 rewards points and they mailed me 2 Nike Dri-fit golf shirts! Fore!!
CSA

Hah great… lol.

I’ll just use the cheapest synthetic that meets the specified specializations in the manual and weight and stick to that one.

Man, everyone is pulling your leg.
If your mom maintained the car well with regards to oil changes and routine maintenance, then just use whichever synthetic oil you find it on the shelf. Mobil 1 Advanced Fuel Economy, Pennzoil Ultra Premium, Quaker State, Even Walmart’s Super Tech Synthetic (usually made by Warren) are good.

If you want to get picky about the oil, head over to Bob Is The Oil Guy board for tribological data and decide yourself. BITOG also has a rebate section to find a current deal.

Please tell us about the Hyundai’s oil change history

By time, how often was the oil changed?

By mileage, how often?

Yeah I’ll ask there.

My mother started doing synthetic 8000km/1 year oild change about 5 years ago.

Midnight, you are completely missing the point here. The people who built the vehicle say every 120000KM or 6 months. End of story.

1 Like

Sorry, I made a mistake. It’s 6000 KM or 6 months.

But what do you mean, I’m simply replying to what people are asking. I haven’t taken any decision yet.

But if I do the recommended manual, I don’t think I need synthetic, it doesn’t specify it. Just the required oil specialization and weight.

I woudn’t recommend exceeding the manufacturer’s time and/or mileage limits, as far as oil changes go, even if you’re using synthetic

Others have opinions which don’t match mine, though