Another BOGUS Puzzler answer - sun/moon

Two bogus answers in a row! The latest asked why your finger at arm’s length can block out the sun’s light, while it can’t block out the moon’s. Here’s the answer given:

"So, why can you stand on earth and block out the sun with your finger, but not the moon?

The answer is, it has nothing to do with the size of the sun, the moon, or your finger. It has to do with the fact that it is daytime when the sun is out and it is nighttime when the moon is out.

So when you do this during the day, the sunlight makes the pupil of your eye smaller and it is easier to block it out with your finger. That is what the daylight does to your eye.

But at night, your pupil dilates, to take in as much light as it can in the darkness of the night. In fact, the only available light is from the moon, right? And then when you put your finger up between your eye and the moon, your pupil is too big. Your vision of the moon cannot be blocked out by your finger held at arm’s length.

Basically, the edges of the pupil are looking around your finger.

So it has to do with how your eye reacts to the darkness."

Nonsense. I did it on my early morning walk, full moon, finger at arm’s length, it blocked out the moon completely.

Driving home last night I thought the moon looked pretty good. Why would I want to block it out?

It was partially blocked out last night anyway.

1 Like

Well were you driving? This is car talk after all

I had a buddy tell me 30 years ago that while driving, you can hold your thumb up and block the view of a motor cycle, he was right…

I saw someone doing this experiment the other day. Only it was the middle of the day and they were mistakenly using their middle finger. Some guy in another car apparently saw it too and was trying to give them some instruction but after many repeated attempts, they gave up…

:wink:

2 Likes

A young girl did that experiment too as she blew through a stop sign. Guess she thought I was the sun. I’m sure her name was Karen.

1 Like