Who's right?

Sorry, it’s a 06 Hybrid! I looked for the bulletin(I asked for and they gave me a copy partly because the bulletin said my tires were too old/worn for them to replace) in my files, but I cleaned them out recently (of course) and couldn’t find it. Maybe the correct year (!!) year will help?

FOUND THE TSB! Went to my car: “perform rear upper control arm update per SERVICE BULLETIN 08-001 cause:F 4191B6 rear upper arms,both-replace s/b# 08-001…” Hope that helps!