For infrequent use, is it better to buy an older pre 80s pre age of plastics car?

You are overthinking this. My 2004 Toyota Corolla sat for a year and a half, due to needing suspension repairs, new front brakes, a new drive shaft, new thermostat and water pump, etc. It started right up with the fuel in the tank, although obviously I replaced the battery, which was very old and swollen. I’m sure that this kind of car could be stored for over a year without even needing a new battery if you disconnect one terminal before leaving. My advice is to buy a used 2003-2004 Toyota Corolla for your vacation home. It’s quite possibly one of the best vehicles ever made.

I know someone that spends about 5 months in Florida. His family is mostly in Central Maryland. The son that isn’t there lives a lot closer to MD than FL. He keeps an old minivan in Florida and drives a Suburban in Maryland.

First thing they replace on all the '60s and '70s cars on Fantomworks is the rotted/cracked/missing rubber in the suspension, front and rear. Modern plastics/elastomers are much longer lived than that old stuff. I never had to replace any ‘rubber’ hoses in my last few cars, each 15 years or more old.

No they don’t. Look at all the sub 10 year old vehicles needing control arms because the bushings are cooked.

My Caprice had original rubber bushings and they were still serviceable unlike a 2018 a coworker has that needed new control arms because it was basically undrivable due to bad control arm bushings.

Say that in 10 years the instrument cluster stops working due to bad capacitors, the engine control isn’t far behind, the CV axle boots need to be replaced, the plastic portion of the radiator has cracked, the engine mounts need to be replaced, it needs an oxygen sensor, the power steering pump and rack are leaking, and various parts of the window regulators, door handles, or power locks need to be serviced? Not saying the Corolla is a bad choice, but maybe an older car would need even less age related maintenance.

Are you going to buy a drum of oil for the old car and store it at the cabin as well? Maybe you can use it to barter with the fur trappers at the trading post?

I owned two RWD Datsun 510s (a '71 and '72)… A manual (that I broke) and an automatic. Strut front suspension, semi-trailing arm independent rear. No CV joints, just U-joints (that needed to be replaced). A 1.6 L OHC 4 cylinder with the most complicated 2 barrel Hitachi carb I have ever rebuilt.

A 71 Saab 99E. FWD with double A-arm suspension front and beam axle rear. The engine was an 1.7 L OHC-4 Saab bought from Triumph installed fore-aft and backwards! It had an Bosch D-Jetronic electronic fuel injection system. Totally analog electronics. Ignition key in the floor that could not be removed until the car was in reverse. It broke (darn plastic part!) so I had to disable the locking part.

I had a 1975 Oldsmobile Starfire V6 4-speed. Double A-arm front, control arm coil sprung solid rear axle. I rebuilt the transmission with V8 spec bearings after I broke it for the 2nd time. Then I rebuilt the V6 with performance parts - bigger cam, ported heads, 4 barrel carb and headers.

All 4 cars had tons of plastic and vinyl in the interiors. I went through gallons of Armor-All trying to keep them looking good.

And considering the Corolla is the best selling car model EVER with 54 Million sold (pub quiz question last night!) clearly they are tough, reliable cars.

Say that in 30 years the instrument cluster stops working due to bad capacitors, the engine control isn’t far behind

There, I fixed that for you.

Caps don’t die that early. It is a late 90s problem, not a 2016 problem.

Very true. The electrolytic cap materials and construction is not your father’s cap anymore. Solid conductive polymers have replaced the older liquid electrolytes that would dry out over time, causing the cap to fail. Electrolytics are still being used as bulk capacitance but they are of the newer designs and last virtually the life of the vehicle in most all cases. In extreme environments like electronics under the hood, they have been replaced by other type of capacitors that are not susceptible to heat and vibration. People tend to latch onto legacy issues and aren’t keeping up with technology advancements that solve older problems…

You beat me to it. It’s the 'I heard that x x x was a problem on this car 20 years ago, so x x x must be problem on all cars, forever" mindset.

Ahh, the days of Armor-All. I came on the scene towards the end of that era. But I do recall, as a youngster, my mother yelling at my brother for using up all the Windex shining up the chrome modulars on his 72 Galaxie.

I’m assuming that this version of Bosch’s fuel injection system was better than the totally-mechanical CIS (constant injection) system on my Volvo. CIS was a problem-ridden mess, and IIRC, I had to have the mechanical fuel distributor overhauled a couple of times.

The addition of electronic controls for fuel injection was a huge improvement over the systems from… The Good Old Days.

The weird factoid about Bosch fuel injection is that the analog electric FI, the D-Jetronic was BEFORE the silly CIS system!

That was the only system on that Saab that didn’t cause any issues!

Mechanical systems had been around for decades before Bosch created the CIS. Bosch even had a mechanical DIRECT injection system installed on the 1954 Gullwing Mercedes 300SL making 175 hp from only a 183 cubic inch six cylinder. Pretty hot for the day.

One of the 5 cluster capacitors in my 1992 Toyota failed in 2025. My 80s bench top multimeter had bad capacitors 5 years ago. This year my 80s or 90s portable AM/FM radio has failed. The 1996 Ford is having problems, and capacitor issues that do not trigger a check engine light is a known issue.

And before that, the Benz V12 in the Me109 also had direct injection, back in 1935. Big advantage over the otherwise great Merlin:

Daimler-Benz DB 601 - Wikipedia

Gosh I’m getting tired of this “Vehicles in the Good Old Days were Better” idea so even if stored in a climate controlled garage …

  1. To quote Neil Young, “Rust never sleeps” and the rust prevention on pre 2000 vehicles doesn’t come close to what you have today in the body, fuel and exhaust components.
  2. Rubber, Plastic and Leather all degrade (dry out) with time, slower if garaged but still degrades. i.e. Look at a 5-7 year old tire, signs of cracking? Flat spots? Not handling like it used to?
  3. With time Oil and more importantly Grease becomes less of a lubricant and more of an adhesive.
  4. If left sitting for an extended time (months) Gasoline becomes a water magnet, degrades and becomes less of a fuel and more of a cause of carb float sticking, injector clogs and fuel line rot..
  5. While for some vehicles replacement parts are easily available and affordable but for many others, finding vehicle specific parts for an old vehicle is like a treasure hunt.

Bottom Line, my experience with old vehicles has been to budget about $1,000 and quite a few hours of my time per year to simply to keep them running but it’s a hobby and I have an understanding wife.

From a more rational viewpoint, owning an old pickup makes no sense when I can rent a NEW pickup from Home Depot for the day for $135 / unlimited mileage and have no further expense or obligation.

Most younger people have never experienced the phenomenon of metal gas tanks leaking because of rust. I had that experience with two cars, a '66 Galaxie 500, and a VW Karmann Ghia. There was no visible rust on the chassis or body of both cars, but the Ford’s tank developed a leak after only 4 years, and the VW began leaking after 6 years. Most likely, they rusted from the inside, as a result of water contamination in the gas.

Replacing the tank on the Ford was particularly… interesting… because it was mounted vertically, above the rear axle.

A plastic gas tank will not rust.

Most of that isn’t true Beancounter or net relevant. The point is buying a 50 year old car for storage and infrequent use may result less maintenance cost than what you think is a fairly good condition 25 year old car. Rust is not an issue when stored properly. Old tires often last 30 years before minimal cracking starts. New tires are in the same condition after 8 years. Older cars allow for greasing suspension components. Newer cars require replacing the part. The vehicle would possibly be run out of fuel and have stabilizer and water absorber added. It’s not a relevant point. There may be more parts available for a 50 year old classic than a 25 year old throw away vehicle.

How old are you $1000 per year maintenance cost vehicles? Renting a pickup for 10 days will cost $1350.

The 1992 Toyota metal gas tank has no rust inside at all. Ethanol does absorb water.

In what dream world does that exist???