Fatigue failure at the narrowest point with a cyclic load from the damper. Seems like the exact point you’d think it would fail… and it did. Congratulations?!?
That’s something I wouldn’t have believed unless I saw it. I’m guessing that part was faulty from the get-go, just took some time for it to fail. Good photos.
Kids car was towed to my house for crank sensor
Than I did: Valve cover gaskets
Flex brake hoses
2 wheel bearings
New brake pads
Still looking for more
Despite all the rain we get in the Pacific NW, rust isn’t really an issue here. But I have seen a rust belt car that relocated here that snapped an axle in half like that. I’ve seen that on a new car too.
Back in 2001 I worked at a shop where the owner thought it would be fun to have one of our loaner cars be a 2000 Beetle. We loaned it out for a weekend, Monday morning it had been towed back with no explanation, no note or phone call. Turns out the left CV axle had snapped in half. The car was new enough there were no complete axles available. I had to assemble a new shaft and boots with the old joints. Customer never said a word about what he was doing with the car.
Was there possibly a ring indented or cut into the shaft to locate the weight? The break was totally through the shaft apparently instantaneously and caused a great deal of heat in separating.
No doubt true, but the axles just snap in half. The Honda itself is still fine, I’d bet!
Perhaps several/many years of driving through that wonderful Minnesota road salt and the resulting corrosion gave that break a head start.
And there is something really awesome about obvious, self-diagnosing auto repairs. They kind of make up for some of the elusive dreaded intermittent problems that cause some mechanics to turn to alcohol, other professions, or into tool throwing madmen.
Nice photos! What kind of torque can that engine produce??
Corrosion would be too superficial to causenough weakness.
Defect in manufacture.
Will Honda replace?
Nope. Watch that video, there was LOTS of corrosion at the same location, caused by water/salt being trapped under the rubber damper. Once there’s corrosion like that, it creates sites where stress is concentrated, resulting in failure.
So it’s not a defective part. It is a poor design, IMO, because it can result in this. I bet there are few/no problem in low-rust locations.