A certified tree hugger's advice for buying clunkers😆

Original title “Stay dirty. New Used Cars are Junk”© changed without my knowledge.

Should be “Registered tree-hugger and Greenie’s” …
Not my advice.

200w

2 Likes

You need to add under $20,000 to the title of the thread… He never said that all used cars are junk… He was specifically talking about used vehicles under 200,000 miles and under $20K…

The price of good-quality used vehicles has partly gone up because of what those vehicles cost when they were new… New vehicles are significantly more expensive than they were 10 years ago, so naturally, that has pushed up the price of comparable used vehicles as well… It’s not necessarily that newer used cars are “junk” — the market and the cost of vehicles have changed considerably…

I found 1200 vehicles within 30 miles of me with under 100,000 miles, under 10 years old, and priced between $14,000 and $17,500. I VERY much doubt that all of them are “junk”.

“Newer Used Cars are Junk”,

Those are not newer used cars, they are older used cars (that Ford is 12 years old). They are too old to be on a new dealer’s used car lot. Respectable dealers don’t sell used cars with 200,000 miles on them.

That YouTube guy is in the entertainment business, not providing real advice. Those old cars are a gamble and buyers should offer accordingly. Trouble is that there are enough people that will finance old car purchases and pay the asking price.

Those are the cars Dave Ramsey refers to as a “$2,000 beater” that one should buy to avoid car payments. Today, they ask $12,000 for the $2K beater Ramsey talks about. People are better off to keep the $20,000 vehicle and avoid those worn-out cars.

Another posted video by RG that does not offer anything of use.

You are correct that no one should finance a used vehicle with 200k miles on it, and that the asking prices for these vehicles are ridiculous considering how much of the useful life has already been depleted. However, the fact remains that buying a used vehicle from the 1990s or 2000s with 200k miles on it is a much better bet than buying a used vehicle from the 2010s-2020s with 200k miles on it. The 1990s-2000s vehicle will be cheap enough to justify the high mileage, and it will be easier to work on when necessary.

The quality of new threads in general on this forum is at an all-time low, and if someone posts a real automotive topic as @CapriRacer did, it gets hijacked every time.

And when someone posts an empty reply with nothing more than criticism for the OP, they acquire “likes”. This doesn’t improve the standard of the forum.

The moderator will blame you for this mischief and delete your thread.

They have access to the edit history. However, they are not going to get involved in what they might consider to be a personal squabble. I say this based on the unacceptable conduct shown here lately that has gone unmoderated.

Totally agree with questioning the “wisdom” of a $2000 beater car.

I place a high value on reliability and frankly repairability on any car that I own/drive. If I have to miss or take time off work to get my “$2000 beater” fixed every month, it’s not saving me anything.

A family member has a 25 year old Chevrolet pickup truck that’s been having the same intermittent problems for years. He’s spent a fortune on different garages “fixing” the problems, only for the same issues to arise with the next few months. Often times the truck won’t start when he needs it, or barely makes it home. He’s convinced he’s “beaten the system” and “saved money” by keeping the same truck all these years. I don’t agree.

But your mileage may vary. :wink:

I used to know a guy who “saved money” by holding onto his old, extremely unreliable AMC Hornet. I, along with his other friends, learned to not include him in our plans for movies, dinner, hikes, and other outings because he was consistently 1-1.5 hours late for everything as a result of that Hornet.

In addition to the social stigma, he lost a job because of his inability to be on time for work, and for missing too many work days as a result of the Hornet. But, he was “saving money”!

Agreed.

I’ve realized there are people who value their time, and people who value their money. But with either path you choose, there’s always a “cost” one way or another.

I think some folks are remembering a $2000 used car being doable, but in the year 2000 or so. Inflated that’s about $4000 today.

There’s tons of $2000 cars at pick a part :wastebasket:

Why we’re tolerating this foolishness is beyond me.

Any used car buyer with a lick of sense can buy a “near luxury” 2012 Buick Lacrosse with less than 100,000 miles for $10,000 or less.

A Full Size vehicle, V6 engine, often with leather interior and with plenty of life remaining.

It ain’t gonna impress your “friends” but they’re not paying your bills.

Good discussion. Whether an older car is a bargain or a gamble comes down to what it costs you over the time you keep it, not just the sticker price. A cheap car with a long list of small problems can cost more in repairs and missed time than a pricier one that simply runs. When you size one up, ask for maintenance records, look for rust and leaks, and get an independent inspection before agreeing on a price. If you’re selling an old or non-running car instead, its value depends on its condition, whether it runs, and what scrap and used parts bring locally, so collecting a few offers is smart. Either way, treat the asking price as a starting point.

Stay dirty guy seems like a repair shop. Vs a car flipper. He seems to have a lot of customers with cheap cars that need major work and quite a few decide to not fix car. So he buys them. Begrudgingly
I think he has a lot of tight, cheap, customers. Haha
He does not seem like a shop with <6yr old cars. Cars that are early in life cycle.

sounds like you might become one

Demand for ‘simpler cars from a simpler time’ has also affected asking prices for good examples of used models from say, 20 - 30 years ago.