Vw does build some excellent performing cars, but their inconsistent reliability along with their poor resale value on some of their models because of this would keep me from buying one. Ford as a brand has been much more consistent. I would lean towards their products, especially if the local dealer had a good rep. The new Focus is a good economy car. Your first fill up will tell you if you made the right choice. You really have little need for anything other than a compact. The only thing I would recommend in the Focus is that you consider the most practical model, 5 door hatch for sure. 25 mpg, (less than 20 city)highway may seem decent for the vw, but you’ll seldom see it in your driving, and the 31 mpg city of the Focus is really appealing.