@BillRussell
Not necessarily
If an excellent car is above the mileage limit, it will be sold as a regular car, not CPO
If a car is in excellent shape, but has new Big O tires . . . and it’s a Benz or Bimmer, for example . . . they will either have to “find” appropriate Michelins or Contis to mount, or it will be sold as a regular used car
In my experience, if a trade-in, lease return needs a set of new tires, that is often “too costly” and it becomes a regular used car. There are x amount of dollars allotted to each cpo candidate, and a set of tires is too expensive. Buffing out a scratch, detailing, etc. is still okay
When I said “find” I meant this . . . if they have a regular used car with new Michelins of the right size, they might swap them with the other car, so that at least one of them can be sold as CPO
If the trade-in, lease return, etc. has an aftermarket windshield installed, it might not be eligible for CPO
any evidence of accident repairs, frame straightening, etc., usually rules out CPO, even if the work was first-rate
If a car has 70,000 miles, and the cut-off for CPO is 60,000 miles, it won’t even be inspected for CPO consideration. Therefore, it didn’t “fail” anything.
In my experience, many/most of the regular used cars didn’t fail the CPO inspection. They just weren’t candidates in the first
What if I trade in a 2 year old Camry with 30K miles to a Honda dealer, because I want a new Accord. The Camry will be a regular used car. Just because it’s not cpo, doesn’t mean it’s low quality. People switch brands all the time.