I went and read the CR article about the oil burners. Looked like a great article to me.
There are several main reasons I don’t agree with those who dismiss those bringing suit as whiners
One is not all the cars in a model year group do it. If all BMW’s of a model did it then one could say it’s normal. They do not all do it, so they can indeed build cars which are not massive burners. They are shipping junk for good money.
I worked in corporate America for over 30 years, and am extremely confident there were peons who complained they were selling junk, sort of like the men who told NASA not to fire that rocket below freezing and were told to shut their stupid mouths.
I am also confident it was management who made the decision to ship junk, not the engineers. I have been wrong before and expect to be wrong again, but that is how corporate systems work.
Next, I am also confident that a specific decision was made which caused that oil burning. It could have been sloppy quality control, but I doubt it. I could write many stories just from my company very similar to this.
Just one quick one, on one minor project every time they retested one of the boxes, there was a 40% chance it would destroy itself. For 18 years, rush-rush management refused to let the techs investigate why a standard test would blow the things up. when I came on the project, I complained and was called a smart aleck for questioning something that had been that way for 18 years. A young idealistic engineer agreed that made no sense, so we sneaked into the test set and discovered that 18 years earlier someone had run a wire to the wrong end of the 100 ohm resistor that was supposed to supply a 100 ohm short test. So, for 18 years, they short tested it at 0 ohms. Not one more ever failed after we re-wired the test set per drawings.
Lastly, I suspect soon enough they will fix it once they realize that the customers aren’t buying the They All Do It routine. And, it won’t be hard to fix since the peons already know why it happens.
Everybody else makes cars that aren’t massive burners, and there are some excellent cars out there. Some of you would have us believing they make some sort of special and different type of car that is to other cars as Jonathon Livingston Seagull was to other gulls. They are not. They would be great cars, although very expensive, if they fix the oil burning problem Until they do, they are selling junk for good money.