Join the Car Talk Community!

Discussion Rules

Welcome to the Car Talk Community!

Want to ask a question or join the discussion? Great! Join now.

Sign In Register

Leaking Valve Cover Gaskets

I took my '02 Subaru WRX in to the dealership to get the brakes inspected, and they told me I have leaky valve cover gaskets, as well as a leaking DOJ seal on the front passenger side axle. The repair cost quoted for these repairs was almost $700...are these things that need to be addressed immediately, or should I check out another mechanic? I have never seen any oil leak reaching the pavement underneath my car, so I'm doubting the severity of this issue, besides the fact that the dealer always seems to find some problem that needs over $500 in work that no other mechanics seem to notice. Let me know what you think....Thanks!!


  • edited March 2010
    I'd get a second opinion. If the valve cover gaskets were leaking you'd see oil spots where you park the car. As you say, dealers are always finding ways to increase their profit.

    What's a DOJ seal?
  • edited March 2010
    Get a second opinion.

    It seems as though many repair shops... dealers,independent,chains,etc. have been headed in this direction. A customer goes in for a concern and the repair shop starts looking for unrelated repairs, the estimates are really high and the work needs to be done right away.

    I have seen this happen alot recently with friends and co-workers. I'm not saying the work doesn't need to be done but the repair shops are putting more and more pressure on customers to have the repairs done right away. A good repair shop will inspect a customers car but will list the repairs in order of importance.

    Brakes and safety related items should be addressed right away but a slight oil leak from a valve cover could wait for awhile.
  • edited March 2010
    I have no idea what a DOJ seal is, they tried to explain it as having something to do with the front axle on the passenger side- not sure what could possibly leaking from there though- definitely going to have another mechanic check it out- Thanks for the reply!
  • edited March 2010
    That's what I was thinking- I don't know much about cars mechanically but I can feel the brakes going, not to mention I have had the car for about 60k miles without them ever being replaced (bought it with 35k on it). They tried to tell me the brakes were ok at first and then only after I began questioning the leaks over the phone did they "re-test" my car and decide that the front pads and rotors probably should be replaced too. Is $500 for new pads and rotors reasonable or should I do that repair elsewhere as well? Thanks for the help!
  • edited March 2010
    I concur with a second opinion. Sounds like the dealership is fishing for a a couple of boat payments.
  • edited March 2010
    $500 is extreme for front pads and rotors, unless your WRX is the STi model, in which case that's about right. But for a standard WRX? No.

    I'd think you could have pads and rotors installed for half that elsewhere.

    You need to find an independent Subaru Guru and get away from the dealer.
  • edited March 2010
    While the perception may be that any repairs recommended by the dealer are nothing more than a fishing expedition to relieve the car owner of their money, this is seldom the case.

    It is common practice while a car is on the rack to look it over for other problems. This not only drums up work for the mechanic and shop but also lets the car owner know of other problems that may exist. Any mechanic who does not do this is lax in my opinion.
    The vast majority of cars that come in to a shop WILL need other things, whether the car owner knows it or not.

    As to the repairs listed, it is quite possible to have leaking valve cover gaskets (or anything else) and not leave spots. Oil has a tendency to blow back and there simply may not be enough there to leave a puddle, or even a spot.
    And the use of the word "seal" is a bit misleading. A DOJ on a Subaru is Double-Offset Joint so this means a halfshaft boot, and the passenger front side boot is the one most prone to failure.
  • edited March 2010
    If the valve cover gaskets were leaking you'd see oil spots where you park the car.
    That isn't necessarily true. Sometimes the oil leaks down onto the spark plugs, or leaks so slowly it doesn't show up as an oil spot. I have a leaky valve cover gasket on my car, but no oil spot in the driveway.
  • edited March 2010
    The DOJ seal is the Department of Justice seal. And you thought "big brother" wasn't watching..................

    Seriously, OK4450 is the Subie Xpert here. His advice is respected.

    And get a second opinion. While I agree with OK4450 that most older cars need things that the owners may be unaware of, I have to agree with Willey's observation that shops are hunting for work (read: revenue) whenever anyone stops in for anything basic. It's a good idea to get a second opinion.

    When I go in for my state inspections I always go early in the month and to the shop that knows me. I've been going there for many years. They know that whatever they find will get corrected but they'll get no business from it. When they find something they usually just let me know and then give me the sticker anyway.
  • edited March 2010
    I just had an inspection done just 2 months ago at a shop that seems to have some good honest employees, and I know they probably just try to get state inspections in and out quickly, but it makes me a bit suspicious of Subaru when this shop didn't notice anything leaking. I understand that the Subaru guys are probably more knowledgeable about my car but without fail they seem to be the only place that finds something that needs repair every time that will cost me $600-$700.
This discussion has been closed.