Join the Car Talk Community!

Discussion Rules

Welcome to the Car Talk Community!

Want to ask a question or join the discussion? Great! Join now.

Sign In Register

Leaking Transmission Fluid

Help! My car is on the lift, and everyone is fighting....I had the transmission fluid changed, and afterwards, it began leaking. I took it back, and was told the transmission cover gasket was leaking....I let them replace it...they said that there may be more than one leak - to keep a check on it. When my check engine light came on I checked the transmission fluid, because it had been leaking again...the level was a little high, but I thought I had maybe checked it wrong. I took it to a different repair shop, and they found that the seal between the engine and transmission is leaking....they will have to drop the transmission to repair this. They said that the fluid was in the normal range. Could overfilling with transmission fluid blow out the seal/o rings/gasket? They say the tech who originally "changed the fluid" is responsible for this problem....Help!
«13

Comments

  • edited November 2008
    I am trying very hard to visualize a seal between the engine and transmission. Could you give some details (make ,model,year,engine type,trans type).

    Maybe a technical name (listed on the repair order) for this seal.
  • edited November 2008
    Overfilling your transmission won't damage any gaskets. The most common source of leaks would be the pan. If the pan was dropped and then put on not using proper torque specs for the pan bolts, that could be your problem. The mating surface of the pan will be bent if the bolts are put on to tightly and will leak. Other than that I can't think of any way a leak could be caused by a trans fluid change. Go to a different shop and get a second opinion.
  • edited November 2008
    The car is a Volvo S40 (2000), automatic transmission. I do not have a repair order in writing...yet. They called me, and told me what they had found.....by the time I got to the dealership the service department was closed....I could see the car up on the lift through the windows......since they were closed for Thanksgiving today, I plan on going to take a look at it tomorrow.
  • edited November 2008
    The front transmission seal is a round seal with metal on the outer diameter and rubber on the inner diameter. It is driven into the front of the transmission behind the torque converter, metal to metal as an interference fit. The rubber seals the transmission's rotating output shaft. Its name is Fred. Get the picture?

    Replacement requires pulling the tranny away from the engine. It's the only way to get to it. Unfortunately it is labor intensive.

    How much is it leaking? A quart a month, week, or day? If the first, you can buy a lot of quarts of fluid for the cost of this repair. Two drops on your garage floor will spread out to a couple of inches in diameter. Looks like a lot, but it really isn't.

    I don't see how changing the fluid could have caused this seal to leak. A fluid change could cause the pan gasket to leak IF the pan were removed during the procedure. Was it done as a "flush and fill" with a machine pumping new fluid into the transmission's cooling lines, or was it done the old fashioned way by removing the pan? That way only changes PART of the fluid.
  • edited November 2008
    First of all, just how high was the level?? Overfilling is not going to raise pressures and cause the pump seal to "Blow" out. The pump could be "venting" It is quite common for a pan gasket to leak after the pan has been removed. Pans need to be perfectly straight when reinstalled. Prying the pan off during service will cause it to leak if not careful so I can see it leaking after the service. If replacing the pan gasket again cured that leak then I would first just clean up the trans and get the fluid to the proper level. If the pump was just venting then the leak should stop from the bellhousing area. Watch it carefully for a couple of weeks because you might still have some residual oil in the bellhousing area that will drip for a short time. If you notice the trans still leaking from the bellhousing area then the trans probably did have 2 leaks and it would be time to remove the trans and replace the front seal and bushing. Let us know how it comes out.


    transman
  • edited November 2008
    I went to look at the car today. It is leaking from the front seal area. The pan gasket (which was replaced) is not leaking. They have left it up on the lift....there was a little puddle of transmission fluid under it....they said that when the car is idling it drips out continually (they did not demonstrate this for me). They said the car is undrivable....that is interesting, because I drove it there. The Volvo mechanic said that they do not "fill and flush" S40"s....I asked why not, and he said they don't need to...that they don't have any problems with the transmission on this model. I asked what happens when they are mechanically flushed....he said he didn't know...they just don't do it. BTW....this car does not have bellhousing....the design has been changed to one piece. The mechanic said he would be very angry, if this was his car, and he indicated that the shop that originally changed the transmission fluid is responsible. He said he didn't know what had happened....sometimes bad things just happen, but that IF I had had the transmission fluid changed at the Volvo dealership, they would take responsibility for repairing the leak...... I also do not know if they used the correct fluid.....
  • edited November 2008
    The only thing I can add is that it sounds like the torque converter (front pump) seal is leaking.
    If so, I don't see a fluid change, pan drop, or even a flush as causing this seal to leak.

    If the gasket that was used on the pan was of the cork variety it's quite possible that gasket could be leaking. I refuse to use a cork gasket for this very reason; it's strictly rubber or cellulose.

    The reason they tell you the car is undriveable is because with a steady transmission fluid drip it would be very easy for the car owner to dismiss it and keep on motoring. This could lead to a fried transmission very shortly and finger pointing over who did what or who was going to be at fault for whatever.

    As to what you're being told by the mechanic about "being angry if this was his car" and they would "take responsibility for this leak if they had changed the fluid" I can only say - utter BS on their part.
    They're simply trying to one-up the previous shops and portray them in a bad light; and believe me, this is not that rare a thing to occur.
    I bet Transman knows what I'm talking about! :-)
  • edited November 2008
    I agree...it just doesn't make sense....all I know is that I didn't have a problem before I had my transmission fluid changed.

    The gasket is gray in color...if that may indicate what it is made of....it looked kind of spongy (maybe rubber or plastic) It looked dry and oil free.

    Yeah...I know....they have me in the middle, and they are trying to make me angry enough to get really aggressive against the original repair shop....I am like a ping pong ball - running back and forth....it is a really long story, and I don't think that is what this list is all about....

    I really appreciate all of the technical information that everyone who responded has given me...I have learned quite a bit about the transmission, and I have been able to ask reasonable questions....Thank-you so much!
  • edited November 2008
    If the torque converter seal is leaking I see no way on earth they're responsible for this. The seal is located between the converter and the transmission. To tamper with this at all means they would have to remove the transmission from the car.

    Here's a couple of possibilities that could cause this. (assuming converter seal)
    Clogged or defective transmission vent. When the fluid gets hot it expands. If the vent is inoperative fluid will try to force out somewhere.

    Another could be a leaking transmission fluid cooler (inside the radiator). The cooling system is under pressure when hot, and especially if the transmission vent is faulty, maybe the cooling systme is pressuring up the transmission internally and forcing fluid out past a seal that may not normally leak.

    I'll reiterate; what you were told by dealership about being angry, standing behind it, yada, yada, yada, is bunk.
    I GUARANTEE you that if a converter seal started leaking after a simple transmission fluid change they would not for one minute stand behind that for free.
    Nor should they.
  • edited November 2008
    This is an interesting piece of information! I didn't mention...the "check engine light" came on...which was the reason that I took it to the Volvo dealership...they said that the reason the light came on, is that the thermostat has been sticking, and that it needs to be replaced (to the tune of $235.00....also my "software" needs to be "updated"....another $163.00). I had not noticed the car overheating....but then again, I do well to look at my gas gauge.... Since I did know that the transmission fluid is cooled by running through the radiator, I asked if this could have caused enough of a problem with the thermostat that this is what the software indicator "picked up"....in other words, I question if there is a real problem with the thermostat...the service manager just said, "that's an interesting question". I didn't realize how "interesting" that possibility might be.

    So....should I ask them to check the water in the radiator for transmission fluid?

    Tell me about this "vent"....where does it vent to? Does excess transmission fluid actually drip out of the car through this vent?
This discussion has been closed.