Camry 2007 Transmission issue

mwbadawy
Wed, 04 Jun 2025 12:41:43 +0000
Maintenance/Repairs

Hey everyone,
I’ve got a 2007 Camry XLE with 117k miles. Since I bought it two years ago (at 107k), it’s always had a slightly rough or delayed shift into 3rd gear — mainly noticeable when the engine is cold or if I don’t let it warm up before driving. Once the car warmed up, it would shift fine.

I’ve taken it to a few mechanics over time, and every time they drive it, they say it shifts normally and can’t replicate the issue. No codes either. So I just lived with it and made sure to warm up the car.

But a couple of days ago, the issue got worse — now it’s a noticeably late or struggling shift into 3rd, especially when I’m going uphill or have the A/C on. Took it back to the mechanic, and again, he drove it for about 20 minutes at various speeds with the A/C on, but said everything felt fine to him. He checked the transmission fluid — said it’s not cherry red but not dark either, and no burnt smell.

He offered to do a full transmission fluid flush and replace it for $420, but admitted he’s not sure it would help. I asked about inspecting the gears/clutches, and he said that would require pulling the whole transmission — $1800 just for that.

I’m kinda stuck here. Both options are a lot of money to gamble on when there’s no clear diagnosis. Has anyone dealt with something similar on a Camry? Any suggestions or things to try before going down the expensive route?

P.S. Since I bought it used, I have no idea if or when the previous owner did any transmission service.

Thanks in advance!

8 posts - 7 participants