Alternator and battery: I thought it was a simple question

Some retail auto parts stores will load-test your battery and alternator gratis. Takes very little time as they have all the equipment. No harm asking. In case you wonder how they can do it for free, well they’ve discovered they find quite a few defective batteries this way, and can recoup their costs on replacement battery sales.

One interesting development in auto- alternators is the amount of computer involvement incorporated in the charging system these days. New cars have a host of accessory systems drawing power, some from the electrical system, and some the engine. Things can get out of whack if too much total power is being drawn. On many newer cars, the computer reads the various sensors, estimates the % of battery charge, etc, and decides based on the situation how much power the alternator should be putting out. For example if the AC compressor is on, and the engine rpm is low, even if the battery charge is low, the computer may decide an add’l alternator load on the engine is no good. So it will put the alternator in low power output mode (by reducing the current to the rotating electro-magnet), in order to prevent drivability problems, like engine stalling.

This level of sophistication seems like a good thing; that is until something goes wrong. Diagnosing charging system problems may soon become the job of a computer technician.