Replaced dead battery in my 2001 Saturn SC1 and now it turns over but won't start?

Thanks so much for the reply! I gave that a try and still no dice. Someone else suggested maybe the engine was flooded so I put the pedal to the floor and tried to start it with no luck. It’s almost as if it’s not getting fuel.

This vehicle has quite the history and the fuel pump was just replaced in Sept 2011. Water pump just before that in June 2011. New alternator (twice, under warranty at Saturn Dealer) in Feb 2010 and March 2009. New starter (twice, once at local shop and second time at Saturn Dealer) in Jan 2009 and Oct 2008.

Ugh I’m not interested in spending more money on this car but I don’t want another car payment either. Do you think it’s just time to cut bait or take it in one more time?