I have an 06 Subaru outback with 98,000 miles. The catalytic converter is shot and our emissions test is coming up soon. The car is valued between 9 and 10 grand. The cat converter fix will cost about 1500. I love my Subaru, but I’m wondering if I should get a new used car. The catch is I can’t aff…

I agree with cigroller. Let’s face it, you are just trading cars, both of which have been problems. Few people sell good cars, they sell or trade the cars they are having problems with. You choice is to buy new (can be expensive) or check out what you are buying carefully and plan on making some …

I’ve always been of the opinion that late model used cars are back on the market for a reason. In many cases that reason is that they need some expensive work, have an insolvable problem, or have been in a wreck. $11,000 is one heck of a lot more money than $1,500. If the car has otherwise been goo…

“As extremely unusual as this is, I can’t totally agree with Cig” Well, mountainbike, I’m just willing to admit that you have more wisdom & experience than I do so I’d say your counterpoint is well taken & I give on it, except that one must still entertain the possibility (but not necessity, as you…

“I’m just willing to admit that you have more wisdom & experience than I do” Naw. Just a slightly different perspective on this one issue. I agree wholeheartedly, however, that if there’s any question as to whether it’s normal “wear & tear” of has some other root cause, any signs of an anomolie hat…

I agree that you need a second opinion to make sure this converter is bad. If it really is, you need to find out why so that you don’t kill the new one for the same reason. I assume the check-engine light is on now. Was it on for a long time before you had this checked, by any chance? Even if yo…

“Even if you need a new one, there’s no way I’d dump a 2006 car because of a $1,500 repair.” My sentiments exactly.

Well, mountainbike - you’ve been crawling around machinery for longer than I’ve been alive. I was just trying to, you know, respect that that without seeming like I was calling you an old fossil! (Oops, too late :wink:

Your Subaru may be covered by this recall/campaign. Check with your dealer. NUMBER: WVM-23 DATE: October 2009 (Revised 03/23/11) SERVICE PROGRAM BULLETIN APPLICABILITY: 2006-2009MY CA PZEV Spec. Subaru Legacy / Outback and 2008-2010MY CA PZEV Spec. Forester SUBJECT: Engine Control Module (E…

Cig, I’ve grown old enough that it no longer matters. And I’m proud to have made it this far with MOST of my sanity intact.

I will check with Subaru on the engine control module issue and get a second opinion on the cat converter. I do love my car. Note: The car is paid off. If I were to get a new one I would sell this one for around 10 grand and use that to go toward a new car. It’s a good point that I might be tradi…

Fix or buy another car

General Discussion

cigroller February 10, 2012, 11:40pm 14

I seriously doubt that you will get $10K for it. That is especially so if it has this converter issue. There’s what you can find about a car’s value via NADA and KBB and Edmunds and stuff. And then there’s the reality of selling a used car - especially if it has an expensive problem.

Topic		Replies	Views
Should I sell (more likely, trade-in) or should I fix? Maintenance/Repairs subaru	11	16753	March 23, 2012
'01 Subaru needs 2 catalytic converters Maintenance/Repairs subaru , catalytic-converters , outback	15	1758	February 6, 2011
Fix or buy new (used) Subaru outback Buying/Selling subaru , outback , selling	9	2126	February 27, 2011
Subaru: new catalytic converter or new car? Maintenance/Repairs subaru , outback	12	25226	October 21, 2011
Catalytic converter Maintenance/Repairs subaru , catalytic-converters , outback	7	5063	March 25, 2017

Fix or buy another car

Related topics