Do new tires need to be balanced or is that just overcharging?

Usually you want them balanced. If you aren’t somebody who wants to act normally, don’t have them balanced. If you could still get new tires for $30 each, you could just say no. I had a Ford Tempo which I didn’t respect and an 87 pickup truck and never balanced the 14 months worth of tires I bought. OK the truck tires lasted three years. I had no problems “that I knew of”. I mean the vehicles had no problems.

Now that I’m spending a lot more for tires, I have them balanced every time and buy the lifetime rotation/balance plan. I sleep a little better now.