Water Pump for 1996 Toyota Corolla - When Should it be Replaced

If this is the originall water pump it should be replaced with the timing belt even if it were not leaking. I’d repace the tensioner too.

IMHO the additional 3 hours labor is too much. He’s probably going by the standard, which indicates three hours to replace a water pump, but that’s assuming the mechanic isn;t already replacing the timing belt. Honestly, whether a shop charges this way or not depends on the shop.