You can make an informed decision, based on the comparative information on the tire rack website, but if you want a specific recommendation, I can give a very strong recommendation for the Michelin X-Ice tire.
Most winter tires suffer from very rapid tread wear, as compared to “regular” tires.
However, the Michelin X-Ice, like most Michelin tires, yields much better/longer tread wear than most of its competition. It handles decently on dry roads (unlike much of the competition), is not as noisey as most winter tires, and is incredibly good on both snow and ice.