So I’m curious: What is the real difference between taking a car to the dealer vs. taking it to an independent garage? What is their motivation? What is the upside or downside to sticking with one or the other? These probably seem like obvious questions, but I’m new to car ownership & could use some…

Again with the specific and useful advice… OK, if you are not a moderator already, you should be. Thank you.

Thanks Hardly, we’ll find out when they open the engine, I guess. Y’know, if they’re honest… haha… gulp.

It’s not only price. The dealership has more training availible to them. The indie does also but not as much. But with that said it also has alot to do with having a sharp tech. Dealerships do not always insist on using thier parts. One qouted me a price on thier brand and I asked them to qoute aft…

it depends on what you are talking about. it took you several posts and replies to even mention an ‘engine’ problem. you should state the whole story, and some relevant details.

Like the others, mostly cost but I’ve had good and bad luck with both. If it is a possible recall issue though, I’d be inclined to go to the dealer. They have a better knowledge of the particular type of car, have seen it before, have specific training, tools, and support. For a newer car, or com…

Thank you Bing, that sounds like very balanced and logical advice.

you don’t HAVE to go to a dealer. but you should find one who specializes in japanese imports. ask friends neighbors co workers for recommendations for a different shops near you.

Dealers in general tend to be more pricey in both labor and parts. I use dealer mostly when car is new and if they satisfy me I stick with them. Recently though my dealer service managers changed and now recommend unneeded by maintenance. Fortunately a really experienced in my car make indy shop op…

OP, just to add a bit here. If you go to the dealer talk to them about this low compression and suspected tight valve lash problem before authorizing any diagnosis or repairs. Try to find out in advance if Honda Motor Co. will good will this repair for you up front IF that is what the problem is. Ba…

Dealer vs. garage: what's the dealio?

Maintenance/Repairs

y00phemism May 8, 2008, 3:39am 17

sure cappy, here is the backstory:
http://community.cartalk.com/posts/list/1041210.page

Topic		Replies	Views
Dealer or not for repairs Maintenance/Repairs mercedes-benz , c-class	20	2263	January 4, 2011
Service Work at Dealership versus Third Part Repair Shops Maintenance/Repairs	18	1673	August 23, 2011
Is there an advantage to having maintenance performed at a dealership? Maintenance/Repairs	62	3630	February 19, 2015
Why do dealers charge so much? Maintenance/Repairs	74	38034	August 31, 2007
Please discuss or flame this observation! General Discussion	43	2670	November 25, 2014

Dealer vs. garage: what's the dealio?

Related topics