Join the Car Talk Community!

Discussion Rules

Welcome to the Car Talk Community!

Want to ask a question or join the discussion? Great! Join now.

Sign In Register

2003 Dodge neon Replace computer?

So I bought this car in october of last year used. It started fine for about 3 weeks then starter clicked 1 time and engine didn't turn over. I replaced the starter&solenoid. Again car started fine for about 3 weeks. I replaced the starter relay switch, car again was fine for another 3 weeks.



A battery and electric car shop told me my battery was old. I got a new battery. Thought that fixed it again but 3 weeks later no start. I had a skim module error code stating my key was the wrong key, I got a new one and car started fine for the next 3 weeks.



If I reset the computer by removing the batter terminal for about 5 minutes this usually will allow me to start my car.



Current error codes:

P0440

P0441

P0456



After a computer reset they all go away for a while.



Should I cut my loses and get rid of this car? Should I replace the computer or perhaps the skim module?

Definitely at a loss here. Any help is totally appreciated and Thanks in advance!!!



-shawn

Comments

  • edited April 2011
    Shawn,

    Codes:

    P0440 Evaporative Emission Control System Malfunction
    - http://www.obd-codes.com/p0440
    P0441 Evaporative Emission Control System Incorrect Purge Flow
    - http://www.obd-codes.com/p0441
    P0456 Evaporative Emissions System Small Leak Detected
    - http://www.obd-codes.com/p0456

    While these are generic listings for *most* vehicles, they may not be perfectly correct for your vehicle. You have a leak in the vacuum system somewhere. Everything I read is pointing to the gas cap. Not the right one, bad or broken seal, or not being tight enough.

    I can't see a reason to replace the computer. That would seemingly be just a waste of money, as it's not the problem, it's merely trying to get your attention and direct you to the real problem.

    Cahse
  • edited April 2011
    So do you think that these error codes are not allowing my car to start occasionally, even though it starts most of the time?

    tx again!

    -shawn
  • edited April 2011
    I do. The computer may be deciding something's wrong enough that it needs to be fixed before proceeding. the codes are stored, and normally one error isn't enough to cause problems, unless it's continuous. Multiple errors are telling it that it's serious enough to stop until fixed. Obviously, it all depends on the error, but these are all pointing towards the same system or set of systems.

    The light is just the cars way of saying "LOOK AT ME! I need help!"

    Good enough for everyone? Comments? Criticisms?

    Chase
  • edited April 2011
    The fault codes you refer to all have to do with the Evaporative Emissions Control system on your car. Essentially, the car contains fuel vapors from the gas tank and eventually sends them to the engine to be burned. This system has nothing to do with why your car won't start.

    The code relating to your key is the direction to look. SKIM, Sentry Key Immobilzer Module, is an anti-theft system that will keep your car from starting unless a "valid" key is used in the ignition.

    Any well-equipped local garage with a decent scan tool should be able to handle this for you. Have the problem diagnosed rather than try to throw parts at it.
  • edited April 2011
    OK, so which of those codes directs me to the SKIM module? The mention of that module was a WAG by the OP, not any of the codes read. Did I miss something here?
  • edited April 2011
    None of the EVAP codes direct you to the SKIM or any other system. They only indicate trouble with the EVAP system, which will not cause a no-start condition.

    I read the OP to state that he had a SKIM related code at some point, that's why I recommended that direction. Sorry for any confusion. I'd say the poster needs to get the car to a place that can do more than just read Generic OBDII codes.
  • edited April 2011
    My car has now been starting fine with no error codes for almost a week now. Just an hours ago I started it up and the engine light came back on. Its now only 1 error code of P0440 Evaporative Emission Control System Malfunction. But at least it's still starting, for now.

    I can't help but think since this is such a sporadic error it may be very difficult/expensive to trouble shoot. Which is why someone probably got rid of the car, and I got such a good deal on it.

    Any more suggestions are greatly appreciated, and thanx again!

    -shawn

  • edited April 2011
    It's not sporadic. It just has to fail the self test X number of times before it will trigger the CEL. I bet if you reset the computer and drove it twice or three times the EVAp code would show up as pending. That means the computer has detected a problem, but it hasn't yet confirmed it as a chronic problem.

    My course of action would be to buy a new gas cap (cheapest option) and if that failed I would either take it to someone, or get a service manual (probably take it in, cause of the SKIM problem).
This discussion has been closed.