Join the Car Talk Community!

Discussion Rules

Welcome to the Car Talk Community!

Want to ask a question or join the discussion? Great! Join now.

Sign In Register

Best "mechanical" car?

Prius owners are chapped en masse for economy numbers less than the window sticker claims while my friend's 1960 Morris Minor continues to get 40 MPG with an engine shared with my long ago MG Midget.
<br/> Pretty much every function of any modest car is now performed via computer chips and servos. There must be cars out there that have resisted this movement for purposes other than a lower sticker price.
<br/> If this set is a number greater than one, do you have any feelings about which is the best "mechanical" car out there? I would love to find the 2010 equivalent of a 1978 Alfa Romeo GTV that did not have the ballast of 700 pounds of electric motors.


  • edited August 2010
    No such critter. Impossible to meet safety/pollution/economy/power requirements without lots of electronics.
  • edited August 2010
    Go to India and buy a brand new Tata.

  • edited August 2010
    Even the Nano has electronic fuel injection...
  • edited August 2010
    You might have luck finding a fully restored 78 AR GTV out there somewhere. Just be aware parts will be hard to find and very expensive to buy.
  • edited August 2010

    ...but be aware that you will not be able to bring that Tata (bodacious though it may be in your eyes) back to the US does not have the electronic equipment necessary to pass any Western nation's emissions tests. It also does not have the ability to accelerate fast enough to get out of harm's way.

    Additionally, it will collapse like Enron upon the slightest impact, and since it has no modern passenger protection built into it, you and your passengers will likely die or be horribly maimed if the impact is anything more than superficial.

    But--it is almost entirely free of the electronic devices that you fear!
  • edited August 2010
    Interesting you chose a 1960 Morris Minor. 1960 was really the very start of pollution control regulations. That Minor probably put out more pollutants (HC and CO, the bad stuff) than 100 modern cars. Ahhh, the good old days....
  • edited August 2010

    Doesn't that Morris Minor have Lucas electrical components?
    You know, the ones made by The Prince of Darkness.
  • edited August 2010
    The advent of pollution controls made the computer controls necessary to get good mpg, good performance, good driveability, and reliable too. The late 70's and cars of the 80's were full of mechanical things to control pollutants but they were also loaded with numerous vacuum lines, tubes, air pumps, and ran lousy in many cases.

    If you want simple get a basic Honda Civic with as few gadgets as possible. Or similar car by the mfg'r of your choice.
  • edited August 2010
    None. Nada. Cannot exist under our present EPA and D.O.T. mandates.

    Besides, electronic fuel injection really is much more reliable, and the systems allow the engine to run much cleaner extending its longevity, than those ol' carbs did. And the airbag systems, steel door beams, unibody construction with energy absorbing "crush zones" built in, add weight but save lives. If your Morris Minor or your Midget got in a crash with any modern car guess who'd win?

    The best you can do today for a basic mechanical platform is probably something like a stripped down Toyota Tacoma. There're no "bells and whistles", just a basic RWD platform with as basic a 4-banger as is available today. I was looking at the brochure yesterday evening and the basic truck doesn't even have the AC automatically turned on with the defroster.
  • edited August 2010
    There are NONE. I don't think you can get an ICE powered lawn mower or weedeater without emissions controls ... many electronic.

    Most autos went to at least pneumatic (vaccum) analog computing and control certainly before the 1980s probably earlier than the 1970s. By the end of the 1980s these vaccum controller were amazingly complex [trouble shooting can be VERY difficult without substantual knowledge]. Vaccum advance was the earliest and simplest of these system.

    When Large Scale Semiconductor Integration (LSI, with increased logic power and internal memory) prices declined in the 1980s ... OEMs started replacing vaccum systems with electronics ... all of which you probably already know.

    MANY of the things Fiat Power Train is doing with their advanced MultiJet and MultiAir technologies could NOT be done by any mechanical system that I can think of.

    So ... if mechanical is what you MUST have ... try to find a PRE-1992 Honda Civic or Accord. Not earlier than 1987. There are still quite a few of these on the road in my area today.

    A friend was telling me about 3 weeks ago that his 90 Accord getting a measured 40+ mpg highway until the timing belt broke. Now he is trying to figure out what is different since the repair that cost him about 8 mpg.

    You can search for fuel economies by make/model back to 1984 using

    If you want to search by mpg [simultaniously city/combined/highway, number of cylinders, transmission, Market Class] back to 1994, use

    Decide what you want and start the "HUNT".

    Hope this helps.
This discussion has been closed.